I wanted to get another post in before the year is out, and this time it has been something which I have been trying to get to grips with over the past couple weeks!
So what I have been trying to do is backup some Blu-Ray movies I got for christmas to my Media Center HDD. There is so much confusion out there right now on the best way to do this! And I can be quite fussy with how I encode!
Firstly, the best app I use for being able to get the data off the disk in the first place is AnyDVD HD. This is an awesome application which automatically removes the encryption, and can allow direct access to the disk. It also has a very handy option of skipping all the ad clutter (Grr Disney…) and taking you directly to the root menu! Nice.
So there are loads of different pieces of software out there which kind of do a job. My requirements are something that’s relatively easy to use, I don’t need to know every tiny detail about the encoding! I just want something that looks and sounds good. If I have 1080p content, I want to retain that resolution, and I also like to keep the original audio source, as for the bitrate I am happy to drop this a bit, as I am far away enough from the TV not to notice the pixelation.
First, to trim the fat off the content, and get what I want, a pretty good piece of software out there is MakeMKV. This is currently a free beta software (see the forum for the latest keys) and allows me to select just the content I want – which is generally just the main movie, the primary HD audio track, and no subtitles etc. This then rips from a Blu-Ray disk resulting in a single MKV file at full quality! These are still pretty big (although smaller than the entire disk) so I still need to compress this down to something more manageable. I quite like the MKV container format, as each file can contain multiple streams of video, audio or subtitles, and you can change between these.
For compression, I have used and like (for simplicity’s sake) UncropMKV. This is a nice and simple application which I can open the MKV file MakeMKV just produced, and alter the bitrate setting to compress the video further. It does not give you an estimated file size, so you may want to experiment to get what you want. I typically halve the bitrate and it’s still fine for my needs… This piece takes a while, so sometimes best leaving this overnight. Once complete, you get a second MKV file in the same folder with -uncropped appended – This is your new compressed version.
This generally gives me enough flexibility to get the main Blu-Ray content onto my PC, Sometimes I would transcode to support the numerous devices I have, which thats a different story for another day!
So you may look at that and think, well that’s not exactely easy to use? Yes – correct and I have been seeking something which is easier and works well, but unfortunately does not fill all my requirements!
Three other pieces of software I came across to assist with this are:
Ripbot - This is a pretty good piece of software, but I found getting things to encode and how I liked tedious and slow… It took ages to process content to rip, and takes some time… Not ideal for any batch processing.
AVS Video Converter - Lovely basic, easy to use piece of software, output some fantastic results, but had 1 fatal flaw in my requirements… I could not encode and keep the original audio source, it was insistent on dropping this to MP3!! Such as shame as this was a very tidy piece of software which was well priced. It also offered conversion directly to a wide range of devices such as xbox, PS3, PMP, iDevices etc.
DVDFab - Have used this software in the past for trying out DVD ripping, and wanted to see how it fares for Blu-Ray, a good well stacked application with lots of features! Unfortunately it did not decode the content correctly to start with, but I think this was down to the codec being used, I switched to CoreAVC and I think this is fixed now (yet to test). However the biggest shame with this feature rich piece of software was that the developer wants a fortune for it!! £150-200. I cannot justify spending that much money on saving a couple of clicks. Shame.
Let me know if you have any questions around the process, and any successes you have had with alternative software!